Contact
GRN Insights

Protecting prevention: what needs to happen next?


Erica Headshot BW

Erica Fletcher

Senior Researcher

Adobe Stock 2061083847

The government’s announcement in the Budget to introduce a new category of ringfenced spending for prevention, known as preventative DEL (PDEL), is an important sign of their commitment to protect prevention spending.

This announcement recognises the challenge that the pressure to respond to acute crisis makes it difficult to invest in preventing problems in the first place. The introduction of PDEL at the 2027 Spending Review is a good first step to addressing this and protecting investment that can improve long-term outcomes.

This is a very welcome development which now raises questions about how PDEL will be designed and implemented, as a new spending category will not deliver a shift toward prevention on its own. Key questions remain around how prevention is defined, how baseline spending will be mapped, and how risks and benefits will be shared.

Our report published this week, Power to Prevent: International lessons on regional funding models for prevention, explores the lessons we can learn from international funding models and how they can enable prevention at a regional and local level.

Three priorities will be particularly important for taking forward the prevention agenda:

  • Clear and shared definitions of prevention and frameworks for tagging spend,
  • Clear agreements on how costs, risks and benefits are shared across government,
  • Sufficient flexibility and capacity for places to develop approaches that respond to local needs.

Shared definitions and prevention spend mapping

A first step towards changing how prevention is funded is understanding how much is already being spent, and on what. A shared definition and understanding of baseline spend is needed to identify where resources can be better aligned and track whether investment is shifting over time.

One good example of this work is a tool being trialed by the Scottish Government to identify and classify planned spending. They distinguish between primary (stops a problem), secondary (addresses early emergence of a problem) and tertiary (stops a problem from escalating or recurring) prevention. A pilot of the tool identified around £3 billion of planned preventative spending within the £20 billion of budgeted expenditure examined across seven budget portfolios. Breaking down that £3 billion, the majority of spend was classified as secondary prevention (42%), followed by tertiary prevention (40%), and then primary prevention (18%).

However, identifying and tagging expenditure is only the first step. This on its own does not demonstrate whether that spending is effective or whether the balance of investment is changing.

For PDEL to support meaningful change, spending data should be connected to outcomes, evaluation and decisions about future investment and resource allocation.

The sharing of risks and rewards

One particular challenge to prevention is that its costs and benefits often fall in different places. A local authority might invest in an early intervention, while the long-term benefits result in reduced demand on public services that come out of the national government’s budget. Without a way to share the costs, risks and gains, individual services have limited incentives to prioritise prevention.

PDEL must therefore be developed collaboratively, with national government working alongside strategic authorities and local partners to agree on priorities, develop investment cases and establish how costs and benefits will be shared.

One of the case studies in our Power to Prevent report examines the Early Intervention Investment Framework in Victoria, Australia, which incorporates prevention into mainstream budgeting. Departments, supported by the state Treasury, submit business cases for prevention interventions for approval and funding. They address the ‘wrong-pocket’ problem by applying a claw-back mechanism against the department who is forecasted to benefit from avoided costs or savings, even if that department was not involved in the business case or delivery of the intervention. This means departments can put forward and deliver preventative interventions without being deterred by the prospect of bearing the costs when the resulting benefits accrue elsewhere.

For prevention to work, there needs to be clear agreements between the organisations involved about who is responsible for delivery, where benefits are expected fall and how any savings, avoided costs, or released capacity will be shared.

Giving places the flexibility and capacity to deliver

PDEL also needs to work in the context of an increasingly devolved system. Places have different needs and resources. For example, a funding model that works for an Established Mayoral Strategic Authority may not work for a place without the same resources.

Prevention funding needs to allow for flexibility in how resources are used locally, and that places have the capacity to make effective use of it. This requires supporting collaboration across services and organisations, investing in data and analytical capability, and building the relationships needed to develop and deliver shared priorities.

Greater Manchester’s Prevention Demonstrator, a model we have previously engaged with, offers a testbed of how prioritising prevention can work in practice. Through Live Well, Greater Manchester is working to bring more joined-up, accessible support into communities.

Strategic Authorities play a key convening and strategic role in coordinating local partnerships and collecting data needed to inform future decisions. Alongside funding for interventions, places must be enabled to invest in the relationships, coordination and capability that enable services to work differently.

A path forward

The Budget announcement creates an important opportunity to rethink how prevention is funded and prioritised. However, the success of PDEL depends on how it is designed and implemented.

Successful prevention is not only about protecting a category of spending. It is also about changing how public services work together and how resources are allocated in the interests of better long-term outcomes.

Our report explores these challenges in more detail and sets out seven recommendations for national and regional government.

As work towards the 2027 Spending Review begins, the report offers international lessons that can offer insight into how England can make prevention a more sustainable part of public service funding and delivery.