Contact
GRN Insights

Making the UK an Innovation Nation: A View from the Outside In


Greg Clark 2024 HS

Professor Greg Clark CBE

Global Advisor, Urbanist and Writer

Innovation Nation Summit banner 1

On 9 October I had the privilege of chairing the Innovation Nation Summit in Manchester, convened by the Growth and Reform Network and hosted by Bruntwood SciTech. It was an unusual day. In one room we heard from the Rt Hon Gordon Brown, the Rt Hon Andy Burnham MP, UK Prime Minister, Sir Paul Nurse, Dame Kate Bingham, Mohamed El-Erian, Lord Darzi, Baroness Vadera, the Mayor of Greater Manchester Bev Craig, and the Secretary of State for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, Rt Hon Jonathan Reynolds MP, alongside founders, investors, universities and civic leaders from Glasgow, Edinburgh, Cardiff, Leeds and many other places. Within 3 weeks, the UK Budget of 28 October had turned several of the ideas we debated into commitments. That is a rare sequence in any country, and it deserves to be noticed well beyond the UK.

I write as someone who spends much of the year in other people’s cities. Over 4 decades I have worked with around 400 of them, and I have learned that the view from the outside in is often kinder, and sometimes clearer, than the view from the inside-out. Seen from abroad, the UK’s innovation debate can sound more anxious than the evidence warrants, and less connected to the experience of its peers than it might be. What impressed me in Manchester is that the Growth and Reform Network has begun to address both.

Greg article image

The Network, a partnership of the Future Governance Forum and Metro Dynamics, inspiringly chaired by Ben Lucas, did 3 things well.

First, it named the problem with candour. Its Summit paper, Making the UK the World’s Innovation Nation, notes that only 36% of the public believe the UK is a world leader in science, while 75% agree that innovation is essential to growth (Growth and Reform Network, 2026a). The public has not given up, they are waiting for leaders to catch up. The paper also sets out what it calls the flashing lights on the dashboard. Business churn, the reallocation of jobs from shrinking firms to growing ones, fell from 31% of employment in 2001 to 21% in 2022. The UK still produces 12% of the world’s most highly cited research, but that share fell by 17.6% from 2018. Only 5% of public procurement contracts went to visible scaling firms in 2024 (Growth and Reform Network, 2026a).

Second, it reframed the question. Rather than asking where innovation happens, the paper asks where a sector can genuinely flourish, what market it serves, and where it must connect to become nationally and globally significant. It identifies 127 clusters across the country, 52 of them in places that lag average productivity, and it insists that the geography of opportunity is often larger than the geography of government (Growth and Reform Network, 2026a). That single sentence would be recognised instantly in Stockholm, Boston, Melbourne or the Basque Country.

Third, it organised the argument into 5 shifts that can be acted upon: diffusion, clusters, scale, dynamism and execution. These were offered as propositions to be tested, not a manifesto to be applauded, and the room tested them hard. The Network’s own account of the day records the commitments the Prime Minister made in his Summit speech: £1bn from UK Research and Innovation over 4 years for clusters with world leading potential, the transfer of the Local Innovation Partnerships Fund to established mayors from 2028, and the ambition for a Good Growth Fund in every area (Growth and Reform Network, 2026b; Prime Minister’s Office, 2026a, 2026b). It also records Gordon Brown’s observation that the UK has around a third as many scale ups per head as the United States, and the stubborn tendency of promising firms to sell or relocate at the £50m to £200m stage. That morning, in an op-ed for The Guardian, he had set out the wider prize: raising Britain to Swedish or Japanese levels of innovation intensity would, over time, leave every household £5,000 better off and add £150bn a year to national income (Brown, 2026). The goal, rightly, is firms that scale and stay.

The Budget then moved the fiscal foundations. It published a Fiscal Devolution Roadmap, brought mayors into business rates retention from 2027/28 and a share of income tax from 2028/29, provided £285m of seed funding for Good Growth Funds, created a £1.5bn devolved borrowing facility from April 2028, and established 9 Business Rates Retention Zones in which authorities keep growth above a baseline for 25 years, as the Budget’s fact sheet for the regions sets out (HM Treasury, 2026a, 2026b; Local Government Lawyer, 2026). The Institute for Government called the roadmap the radical reform in an otherwise quiet budget (Pope, 2026). The Network had anticipated exactly this moment. Its September 2026 report, From Fiscal Devolution to Good Growth, argued that fiscal devolution and institutional capability must be designed together, and that national government has to change as much as local government if power is to move out of Whitehall (Lucas et al., 2026). Writing in The MJ 8 days before the Budget, in ‘Forging the Innovation Nation’, Ben Lucas made the same case from the Summit itself: innovation is now central to how Britain can return to a higher level of inclusive growth, and it should therefore sit at the heart of regional and local growth plans (Lucas, 2026). The Academy of Social Sciences, in Perspectives on Achieving Good Growth in the UK, reaches a similar conclusion from a different direction: good growth requires a systems approach, coordinated over the long term and informed by evidence (Grundy, 2026).

So what can the outside-in view add?

The first and most important point is reassurance. The UK’s predicament is not unique, and it is not terminal. Almost every city I admire as an innovation economy arrived there through reinvention after a period of doubt.

Stockholm is my favourite example. In the 1970s it was the model corporate capital, home to Ericsson, Volvo and a consensus approach to economic life. By the 1990s those advantages no longer carried the same logic in a world of mobile talent and digital platforms. Stockholm’s answer was not a grand institutional reform. Municipalities across the region came together in the Stockholm Business Region around a shared story, Stockholm: The Capital of Scandinavia, and used that coalition to align inward investment, entrepreneurship support, and international promotion. A decade later the region had become one of the world’s most prolific unicorn factories, the home of Skype, Spotify and Klarna (Clark and Moonen, 2015). Today the same habit of coalition is building Hagastaden around the Karolinska Institutet, planned for 50,000 jobs by 2035, within a Stockholm and Uppsala region that hosts more than 1,800 life sciences companies (Stockholm Business Region, 2025; Hagastaden, 2026). Stockholm teaches the clusters shift: connect at the scale of the real economy, and build trust before structure.

Bilbao offers the lesson of execution. In the 1980s the city faced industrial collapse, population loss and political violence. In 1991, 16 public and private institutions founded Bilbao Metropoli 30 to secure cooperation across every level of government behind a single strategic plan. In 1992 Bilbao Ría 2000 brought the tiers of government together with the port, the railways and the largest landowners to assemble and redevelop obsolete industrial land. The Guggenheim, which opened in 1997, was the symbol of a programme of 25 projects over 25 years, not the strategy itself. The discipline was striking: budgets were tied to the plan, and the city was debt free by 2012 despite financing around a billion euros of infrastructure since 2003. Behind all of this sits the Basque fiscal settlement, under which the provincial governments raise most of their own taxes. Fiscal responsibility built fiscal capability: forecasting, investment appraisal and the confidence to borrow against a credible pipeline. That is precisely the capability the Network’s September report asks the UK to build alongside its new fiscal powers. Bilbao Metropoli 30 is now in its 35th year. Institutions that outlast electoral cycles are the hidden infrastructure of innovation.

Boston speaks to diffusion and scale. Its earlier technology economy along Route 128 faltered in the late 1980s as the minicomputer firms lost ground. The region reinvented itself around life sciences, anchored by its universities and teaching hospitals, which act as researchers, customers, and early adopters at the same time. Greater Boston now holds around 56m square feet of laboratory and research space, the largest concentration in the world, with about 130,000 life sciences workers, and in 2024 it attracted $3.1bn of National Institutes of Health funding and $7.3bn of life sciences venture capital (CBRE, 2025). The Commonwealth of Massachusetts reinforced that strength with a 10 year life sciences programme from 2008. Yet Boston also carries a warning. Massachusetts biopharmaceutical employment fell by 3.1% in 2025, its first annual decline in more than 20 years (Saltzman, 2026). Even the strongest cluster remains exposed to national funding decisions and capital cycles. The Summit paper’s phrase, that research strength is real but fragile, applies in Cambridge, Massachusetts as much as in Cambridge, England.

The same patterns appear in North America’s other innovation regions and right across the Pacific.

Toronto shows what dynamism looks like at scale. Its innovation economy was built through an unusually deliberate set of intermediaries: the MaRS Discovery District, opened in 2005 beside the University of Toronto and the city’s teaching hospitals, and the Vector Institute, launched in 2017 to keep the deep learning talent that grew around Geoffrey Hinton’s work in the city. Civic leadership mattered too. CivicAction has built a shared evidence base across a fragmented region and incubated initiatives no single government could have launched alone. The decisive ingredient, however, is people. Toronto added 75,000 technology jobs between 2022 and 2025, more than any other North American market, and now ranks third on the continent for tech talent, behind only the San Francisco Bay Area and Seattle (CP24, 2026). Nearly half of the metropolitan population was born outside Canada. Connected along a corridor to Waterloo, Toronto reminds us that openness to talent is an economic strategy, not simply a social virtue.

San Diego shows the power of intermediaries. Its innovation economy was seeded in the 1960s and 1970s by the University of California San Diego, the Scripps Institution of Oceanography and one of the world’s largest concentrations of military research, and it grew into one of the world’s leading biotechnology clusters. What converted proximity into productivity was a network of institutions that matched capital to ideas, talent to companies and companies to customers. Foremost among them was CONNECT, founded at UC San Diego in 1985. Life sciences now generate more than US$50bn of regional economic impact and over 75,000 direct jobs, within a regional economy of around US$270bn (Gille, 2026). San Diego also teaches humility. Its median home price reached around US$900,000 by 2024, and the gains of the knowledge economy have reached too few of its southern neighbourhoods, which is why the San Diego Regional Economic Development Corporation, working with Brookings, set measurable inclusive growth goals for 2030. Combined with Tijuana, it forms a binational metropolis of more than 5 million people, a reminder that functional economies cross national borders as well as municipal boundaries.

Melbourne shows what a subnational government can do as a patient investor. As Ford and Toyota ended car manufacturing in Victoria in 2016 and 2017, the state invested deliberately in the knowledge industries that would replace it. The Parkville precinct now brings together more than 40 biomedical organisations, including the University of Melbourne, the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute, CSL and the major teaching hospitals. It employs around 73,000 people, contributes A$3.6bn a year to the economy, secures more than A$1bn of competitive research funding annually and originates 20% of Australia’s health related patents (Invest Victoria, 2026). The state’s Breakthrough Victoria fund co-invests in commercialisation, including the Jumar Bioincubator alongside CSL, WEHI and the University of Melbourne. For a UK now creating Good Growth Funds, Victoria shows what a subnational investment vehicle can achieve when it is given scale, a long horizon and a clear sectoral focus.

Kitakyushu is the case I most often recommend to the UK’s industrial regions. Once a byword for pollution, the city lost its integrated steel production from the late 1970s, and its population fell from around 1.07 million at its peak in 1979. Rather than treating environmental clean up as a cost, Kitakyushu made it an industry. The Eco-Town at Hibikinada, opened in 1997, became a pioneer of industrial symbiosis and the circular economy. The Kitakyushu Science and Research Park brings 4 university campuses and more than 130 research institutes and companies together on a single site, and has moved successively from recycling into robotics, materials science, AI and hydrogen. Close partnership with national ministries and agencies has given the city a hydrogen strategy built around its port and its heavy industrial users, and Japan’s largest offshore wind farm began operating there in 2026 (Gille, 2026). Kitakyushu teaches that decarbonisation can be designed as competitive specialisation, and that a well funded intermediary can outlast administrations, policy cycles and economic shocks. The East Coast energy corridor, Teesside and the Humber should find much to admire there.

Kaohsiung shows how quickly a heavy industrial city can be repositioned when local initiative and national strategy align. Long defined by its port, steel, shipbuilding and petrochemicals, the city proposed a southern semiconductor corridor linking science and industrial parks across Tainan, Kaohsiung and Pingtung, and the national government adopted it as part of its ambition to rebalance high technology industry between the north and south of Taiwan. TSMC’s Nanzih campus sits on the site of the former Kaohsiung oil refinery (Kaohsiung City Government, 2022). It broke ground in 2022, completed trial production of 2 nanometre wafers ahead of schedule in October 2025, and is planned to have 5 fabs in operation by the end of 2027 (TrendForce, 2025). Alongside it, the Asia New Bay Area has turned the old harbour front into a district of exhibition, music and software. The mayor proposed, the national government endorsed, and the private sector invested. Kaohsiung is a vivid illustration of the Summit paper’s argument that the path to re-industrialisation runs well beyond the established centres.

Busan is a case to watch rather than a case to copy. Korea’s second city and home to one of the world’s busiest container ports, it has been losing young and educated people to Seoul for two decades. Its response combines placemaking with national legislation: the Eco Delta Smart City, one of 2 national pilot smart cities designated in 2018, and a proposed Global Hub City Special Act that would create international logistics and finance zones, investment promotion districts and a coordinating committee chaired by the Prime Minister. In March 2026 the bill cleared a subcommittee of the National Assembly with cross party support, but local commentators rightly observe that a legal basis for support is not the same as money in motion (Breeze in Busan, 2026). Busan’s lesson for the UK is one the Network has already drawn: new powers matter only when they arrive with the capability, budgets and operating detail to use them.

Elsewhere in Europe and North America, others tell the same story in different accents.

Eindhoven rebuilt itself after the restructuring of Philips in the early 1990s through the Brainport partnership of firms, universities and government, and is now home to ASML and a dense advanced manufacturing supply chain. Helsinki turned the decline of Nokia into a start up generation. Pittsburgh grew robotics and autonomous systems from the legacy of steel. Greater Manchester itself, as I have argued elsewhere, built its combined authority on 2 decades of voluntary collaboration and a shared evidence base before formal powers arrived. Seen from abroad, Manchester is not a city waiting for permission. It is one of the UK’s most persuasive exports.

Placed alongside these cases, the 5 shifts look less like a domestic policy agenda and more like a distillation of what works internationally.

On diffusion, Boston and Melbourne show the value of anchor institutions, above all teaching hospitals, that buy, test and adopt, while San Diego shows that intermediaries are needed to carry ideas from laboratory to market. The UK’s figure of 5% of procurement reaching scaling firms is therefore an opportunity hiding in plain sight, and the Budget’s decision to appoint an external chair to the Commercial Innovation Hub, intended to drive innovation through public procurement, is a welcome first step (Local Government Lawyer, 2026).

On clusters, Stockholm, Eindhoven and Kaohsiung show that functional geographies win, and San Diego and Tijuana show that they can even cross national borders. That is why the Network’s emphasis on connected corridors, from the North West and the Cambridge and Manchester partnership to Bristol and Cardiff, Glasgow and Edinburgh, and the East Coast energy corridor, is so well judged.

On scale, Stockholm’s unicorns drew on global capital and global alumni, and Victoria’s Breakthrough fund shows that subnational capital can share the risk of commercialisation. The UK’s reforms to direct more pension capital towards growth firms, together with regional vehicles such as Greater Manchester’s Good Growth Fund, follow the same logic.

On dynamism, every successful innovation city I know is open to talent, and Toronto is the clearest proof. The Prime Minister’s observation that more than half of the UK’s 100 fastest growing companies last year were founded by people who came to Britain would resonate in Toronto, Boston and Stockholm alike (Growth and Reform Network, 2026b).

On execution, Bilbao and Kitakyushu remind us that long horizons, trusted conveners, enduring intermediaries and budgets tied to strategy matter more than any single announcement, while Busan reminds us that legislation without capability is only a beginning.

There is also something the UK offers the world in return. Few large economies are pursuing what the UK is now attempting: to make innovation the explicit instrument of good growth across every nation and region, and to pair it with a serious programme of fiscal devolution.

Europe’s network of medium sized cities, and many metropolitan regions in North America and Asia, face the same question of how national science strength becomes local prosperity. If the UK gets this right, it will provide a model that others study, much as the world has studied Boston and Bilbao.

Getting it right will require patience and honesty. The Network’s Summit paper asks the right closing question: what should be demonstrably different in 5 years, and in 10, if innovation had genuinely become central to the growth model? The outcome measures it proposes, from more innovation active firms and stronger adoption to more places converting distinctive strengths into competitive positions, give the UK a scorecard that international partners and investors can follow (Growth and Reform Network, 2026a). The places that publish such scorecards, and keep them for a decade, are the places that earn the presumption of competence.

I want to close with thanks. To Rt Hon Gordon Brown, whose leadership reminded us that the places that built Britain can rebuild Britain. To Ben Lucas, Charlotte Alldritt and Joe Burns, and to the teams at the Future Governance Forum and Metro Dynamics, for a paper of real quality and a day of real substance. To Lord David Sainsbury for supporting the event, and to Jessica Bowles and Bruntwood SciTech for hosting us. To every speaker and participant who brought candour rather than comfort.

In the coming weeks I will share the Network’s reports with my international colleagues. This week I also talked with Ben Lucas for The Century of Cities about what the UK is attempting and why it matters beyond these shores, and you can listen to our conversation here: Can Britain's cities unlock their economic potential?. For two centuries the UK was the innovation nation. From where I stand, looking in from the many cities I work with, it has every chance of becoming one again.

To read the work behind this essay, start with the Growth and Reform Network’s Summit paper, Making the UK the World’s Innovation Nation, and its account of the Summit and the 5 shifts. Its September report, From Fiscal Devolution to Good Growth, sets out the capabilities that fiscal devolution will demand. Ben Lucas’s ‘Forging the Innovation Nation’, first published in The MJ, Gordon Brown’s op-ed in The Guardian and Adam Terry’s ‘Britain Should Rediscover Its Role as the Innovation Nation’ make the case in brief. For the Budget, see the Fiscal Devolution Roadmap and the fact sheet for the regions. You can follow the Network on its website and on Substack.

References

Breeze in Busan (2026) ‘After the spectacle, what does Busan’s global hub bill actually change?’, Breeze in Busan, 24 March. Available at: https://breezeinflow.com/busan-news/after-the-spectacle-what-does-busans-global-hub-bill-actually-change (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Brown, G. (2026) ‘British households would be £5,000 richer if we were more innovative. Let’s unleash our talents’, The Guardian, 9 October. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/oct/09/gordon-brown-british-households-5000-richer-innovation (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Clark, G. and Gille, B. (2026) The soft power of cities: seven domains of influence beyond authority. London: Bloomberg LSE European City Leadership Initiative.

Clark, G. and Moonen, T. (2015) The density dividend: Stockholm case study. Washington DC: Urban Land Institute.

CBRE (2025) Boston-Cambridge Market. Global Life Sciences Atlas. Available at: https://www.cbre.com/insights/local-response/global-life-sciences-atlas-market-profiles-boston-cambridge (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

CP24 (2026) ‘Toronto ranks third in tech industry talent across North America’, 19 August. Available at: https://cp24.com/local/toronto/2026/08/19/toronto-ranks-third-in-tech-industry-talent-across-north-america (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Gille, B. (2026) Cardiff Capital Region 10 Year Review, Paper 3: international case studies and lessons for CCR. Unpublished working paper, July 2026.

Grundy, S. (2026) Perspectives on achieving good growth in the UK. London: Campaign for Social Science, Academy of Social Sciences. Available at: https://doi.org/10.4135/wp.261026 (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Growth and Reform Network (2026a) Making the UK the world’s innovation nation: Innovation Nation Summit paper. London: Growth and Reform Network. Available at: https://growthandreform.org/resource-hub/innovation-nation (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Growth and Reform Network (2026b) ‘What are the five shifts we need to adopt to make the UK a leading Innovation Nation?’, Growth and Reform Network, 22 October. Available at: https://growthandreformnetwork.substack.com/p/what-are-the-five-shifts-we-need?utm_source=substack&utm_campaign=post_embed&utm_medium=web&embedding_publication_id=8876110 

Hagastaden (2026) About Hagastaden. Available at: https://www.hagastaden.se/en/about-hagastaden/ (Accessed: 12 November 2026).

HM Treasury (2026a) Fiscal Devolution Roadmap. London: HM Treasury. Available at: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6ae103627b7111c482d80a99/Fiscal_Devolution_Roadmap.pdf (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

HM Treasury (2026b) ‘Budget 2026 fact sheet: delivering for every region’, GOV.UK, 28 October. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/budget-2026-fact-sheet-delivering-for-every-region (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Invest Victoria (2026) ‘Parkville precinct’. Melbourne: Victorian Government. Available at: https://www.invest.vic.gov.au/set-up-your-business/melbourne-precincts/parkville-precinct (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Kaohsiung City Government (2022) ‘Kaohsiung to become the world’s highest valued semiconductor industry cluster’, Business Wire, 8 June. Available at: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220608006211/en/Kaohsiung-to-Become-the-Worlds-Highest-valued-Semiconductor-Industry-Cluster (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Local Government Lawyer (2026) ‘Autumn Budget 2026: key measures’, 28 October. Available at: https://localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/governance/396-governance-news/102085-autumn-budget-2026-key-measures (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Lucas, B. (2026) ‘Forging the innovation nation’, The MJ, 20 October. Available at: https://www.themj.co.uk/forging-innovation-nation (Accessed: 2 November 2026). Republished by Metro Dynamics, 21 October. Available at: https://www.metrodynamics.co.uk/blog/2026/10/21/forging-the-innovation-nation (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Lucas, B., Springer, E., Thompson, J., Ali, H. and Lindsell, E. (2026) From fiscal devolution to good growth: building the capabilities to make it work. London: Metro Dynamics and Future Governance Forum for the Growth and Reform Network. Available at: https://ign.ams3.digitaloceanspaces.com/files/Report-From-Fiscal-Devolution-to-Good-Growth-Final-4.pdf (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Pope, T. (2026) ‘The fiscal devolution roadmap is the radical reform in an otherwise quiet budget’, Institute for Government, 30 October. Available at: https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/fiscal-devolution-roadmap-radical-reform-otherwise-quiet-budget (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Prime Minister’s Office (2026a) ‘Prime Minister to hand regions innovation funding to build world leading industries’, GOV.UK, 9 October. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/prime-minister-to-hand-regions-innovation-funding-to-build-world-leading-industries (Accessed: 2 November 2026).

Prime Minister’s Office (2026b) ‘PM speech at the Innovation Nation Summit: 9 October 2026’, GOV.UK, 9 October. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/pm-speech-at-the-innovation-nation-summit-9-october-2026 (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Saltzman, J. (2026) ‘Biotech lost jobs for the first time in two decades. But things might be on the upswing.’, The Boston Globe, 25 August. Available at: https://www.bostonglobe.com/2026/08/25/business/massachusetts-lost-biotech-jobs-first-time-2025-new-report-shows/ 

Stockholm Business Region (2025) ‘Life Science Success Returns: BIO-Europe Chooses Stockholm for 2027’, 8 December. Available at: https://press.stockholmbusinessregion.com/press-release/life-science-success-returns-bio-europe-chooses-stockholm-for-2027/

Terry, A. (2026) ‘Britain should rediscover its role as the innovation nation’, State and Nation, Future Governance Forum, 15 October. Available at: https://futuregovforum.substack.com/p/britain-should-rediscover-its-role?utm_source=substack&utm_campaign=post_embed&utm_medium=web&embedding_publication_id=8876110 

TrendForce (2025) ‘TSMC Kaohsiung fab hits 2nm trial production ahead of schedule’, TrendForce News, 7 October. Available at: https://www.trendforce.com/news/2025/10/07/news-tsmc-kaohsiung-fab-hits-2nm-trial-production-ahead-of-schedule-a14-reportedly-under-evaluation/ (Accessed: 2 November 2026).