Contact
GRN Insights

What are the five shifts we need to adopt to make the UK a leading Innovation Nation?


Ign profile 2023 10 16 140009 rarp

Growth and Reform Network

Image 7

On Friday 9th October the Growth and Reform Network hosted the Innovation Nation Summit in Manchester, bringing together leaders from government, business, universities, investment and local and regional government to ask how the UK can turn its abundance of invention into an abundance of growth. The day was convened by the Rt Hon Gordon Brown and opened by Prime Minister Andy Burnham, and the programme included contributions from Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, AI Minister Kanishka Narayan, Mayor of Greater Manchester Bev Craig, Baroness Shriti Vadera, a video address by Sir Tim Berners-Lee and Chancellor John Healey, alongside leading founders, investors, business leaders and regional voices.

Innovation is central to the GRN’s mission to raise the trend rate of growth and move to a more preventative state. In Manchester, we tested the five shifts outlined in our conference paper (prepared with Metro Dynamics) which are necessary for innovation: diffusion, clusters, scale, execution and dynamism. Here is what we learned from the day and how it fits into the shifts.

1. Diffusion - How we ensure that innovation is adopted everywhere

The state must become an innovation state 

The UK produces more innovation assets than it uses - in health, energy, AI and science, the barrier is often too few buyers rather than too few products. Spreading innovation to every postcode, so that no place or talent is left behind, means the innovation state must do three things.

The state must be the first customer - The Prime Minister spoke about using public procurement to back British business, and discussions in the day argued the state should go further, with advance market commitments and procurement that favours innovative scale-ups.

The state must set an innovation mission and design R&D funding around it - A big increase in clinical trials, run in every postcode, sits at the heart of the dementia mission that the Prime Minister called for and of the wider shift to prevention. With over £80bn going into research and innovation in this spending review, funding should be organised around clear missions that reach every part of the country.

The state must be central to driving adoption - Adoption of AI and new technology is the UK’s weakest link, so the state should move first, with rapid adoption across the NHS and public services, to spread growth to every postcode.

2. Clusters – We need to scale and connect our clusters around our biggest growth-potential industries

Scale, connect and nurture our local clusters

The UK has an abundance of local innovation assets, with 127 clusters identified in our conference paper, but they need to scale quickly and connect. The Prime Minister announced £1bn from UKRI over four years to back the clusters with the potential to be world-leading, and called for more collaboration between complementary clusters, with the Greater Manchester-Cambridge Partnership as the template. The next stage beyond the Ox-Cam Arc includes a North West supercluster and corridors such as the East Coast energy innovation corridor, Edinburgh-Glasgow, Derby-Coventry advanced manufacturing and Bristol-Cardiff, each connected to European and international innovation partners.

Creating the right innovation eco-system

Connecting local clusters, however, also begs the question about how to grow and develop them. Strong clusters exist everywhere, but many are underperforming. The recurring ingredients identified throughout the day were a long-term, bottom-up plan held for a decade or more; a trusted convener or cluster-management body; business, universities, local government and finance in the room together; and active links between places. Having all the players on the pitch is not enough without an active triple helix approach to force collaboration and tough decisions on where to focus and how to grow.

3. Scale – We need to grow and scale the innovative assets we have

The UK has a conversion problem, not an invention problem

The UK is strong on research, spin-outs and start-ups, but the day made clear that the weak point is what happens next. Gordon Brown set out the scale-up gap: the UK has about a third as many scale-ups per head as the US. Promising firms too often sell or relocate at the £50m to £200m stage. The goal is firms that scale and stay, with jobs, R&D and headquarters anchored in the UK.

Drive more capital investment – with the right conditions - into innovation

UK pension funds invest very little in UK growth companies, so the returns and the ownership go elsewhere. The Prime Minister committed to directing more UK pension capital to British high-growth firms. The Mansion House agenda still needs to be delivered, and regional vehicles such as the Greater Manchester Good Growth Fund, which mobilises local pension capital, should be replicated in other regions.

However, simply driving more money into the system is not enough - the conditions must reward risk. Gordon Brown made the case for a public-private partnership model to scale up innovation investment beyond the roughly £86bn held by existing public finance institutions, and pointed to the R&D tax credits he introduced as Chancellor as an example of incentives that work.

4. Dynamism - We need to back the future and let talent from every background break through

The need for more talent and risk appetite

Growing companies need talent quickly and a culture that tolerates risk. That means fast routes for global talent, an end to non-compete rules for start-ups and scale-ups - as per the Prime Minister’s announcement, reskilling for existing workers, and entrepreneurship that is rewarded in universities. He also noted that more than half of the UK’s 100 fastest-growing companies last year were founded by people who came to Britain. An additional point that emerged from the summit is that the talent scale-ups most need is experience, meaning people who have built and scaled companies before, which the UK still lacks.

Dynamism needs to be supported by the education and skills systems. The Prime Minister highlighted the education system must be reshaped to be innovation-ready, with parity between academic and technical routes and clear pathways into the innovation economy through work placements and apprenticeships, so that no one is excluded from the system.

5. Execution - We need to act together, with leadership and purpose, to deliver the plan

Put innovation at the heart of a 10-year plan

Inward investors believe in the UK’s innovation assets but are not yet convinced of its long term commitment to creating the right conditions for innovation to thrive. The 10-year growth plan must be credible across parliaments, with broad agreement about the role of each part of the system and sustainable commitments to innovation outcomes under the five shifts. It needs a few visible success stories, a clear political case for innovation and for AI, and measures people can feel in their pockets, underpinning the government’s agenda for good growth in every postcode.

Government must drive a connected innovation system

National, regional and local government need to be connected with business, science and universities, so that national industrial and innovation strategy is rewired to link with local and regional growth plans. The Prime Minister announced Local Innovation Partnership Funds for established mayors from 2028 and set out the ambition for a Good Growth Fund in every area. Devolution is a means to innovation: money must be spent on excellence, deliver better outcomes, and be matched by capability on the ground.

The UK is not short of research, talent and ambition, and what it needs now is the delivery and plan to match its ambitions: a state that buys and adopts innovation, clusters that are connected, scaled and confident, and a plan that investors can trust to last. The Growth and Reform Network will keep working with government, businesses, regional and local leaders to turn that momentum into growth in every postcode.